LogoLogo
diffblue.comFree trial
  • Discover Diffblue Cover
  • Get Started
    • What is Diffblue Cover?
    • Get started
      • Free trial
      • Get started - Cover Plugin
      • Get started - Cover CLI
      • Get started - Cover Pipeline
      • Get started - Cover Reports
    • Specs & Reqs
    • Reference Deployments
    • Licensing
      • Online license activation
      • Offline license activation
      • Diffblue License Manager
    • Update Cover
    • FAQs
    • Diffblue Learning
      • Get started
        • Just the basics
        • Free trial
        • Cover Plugin (IDE)
        • Cover CLI (Command Line)
      • Developer
        • Unit tests (IDE)
        • Unit tests (CLI)
        • Test coverage
      • DevOps
        • GitHub
        • GitLab
        • Other CI
      • Administrator
        • Admin - IntelliJ
        • Admin - CLI
        • Admin - Reports
      • Test coverage
        • Developer
        • Senior developer
        • Cover Reports Administrator
  • EVALUATION & ONBOARDING
    • Proof of Value
    • Jumpstart
      • Prerequisites for onboarding
      • Phase 1: Up and running
        • Module 1: Create your Cover unit test baseline
        • Module 2: Cover Pipeline CI integration
      • Phase 2: Developer productivity
        • Module 3: Getting started using Cover
        • Module 4: Introduction to Cover Reports
      • Phase 3: Advanced topics
        • Module 5: Speed up your test execution
        • Module 6: Getting more from Cover
  • Features
    • Cover Plugin
      • Writing tests
        • Gutter icons
        • Menu options
        • Run configurations
        • Cover Plugin tool window
        • Test Review
        • Test examples
        • Creating partial tests
        • Creating skeleton tests
        • Covering all enum values
        • Test insertion order
        • Diffblue Sandbox
        • Environment Check Cache
      • Project configuration
        • General dependencies
        • Test framework dependencies
      • Cover Plugin settings
        • Test Naming
        • Test Formatting
        • Spring configuration options
        • Method Annotations
        • Test Directory
        • Reset Cover Plugin settings
      • Cover Plugin admin
        • Core Maintenance
        • Cover Plugin toolbar menu
        • Cover Plugin status bar widget
        • Telemetry
        • Memory management
        • Using SonarQube with Cover Plugin
        • Log files
        • Troubleshooting
    • Cover CLI
      • Writing tests
        • Command summary
        • Test examples
        • Creating partial tests
        • Customizing test inputs
        • Customizing test setup
        • Test naming
        • Test formatting
        • Test insertion order
        • Patch files
        • Diffblue Sandbox
        • Operational behaviors
        • Test validation
      • Project configuration
        • Preflight checks
        • General dependencies
        • Test framework dependencies
        • Compiling your project successfully
          • Building a Maven project
          • Building a Gradle project
        • Configuring Cover to work with your project's build system
          • Quick guide
          • Configuration file in detail
          • Getting Started with Ant Projects
          • Default configuration
        • Mocking using Mockito
        • Spring profiles
        • Runtime environment
      • Commands & Arguments
        • Environment configuration for CI
        • Packages, classes, and methods
        • Quoting command line arguments
        • Argument files
      • Cover CLI admin
        • Core Maintenance
        • Telemetry
        • Memory management
        • Using Cover CLI in Eclipse
        • Using SonarQube with Cover CLI
        • Log files
        • Troubleshooting
      • Environment Configuration
    • Cover Pipeline
      • Cover Pipeline for CI
        • Quick Start - General
        • Quick Start - Jenkins
        • Quick Start - Azure Pipelines
        • Quick Start - AWS Codebuild
        • Integrating Diffblue Cover into CI on pull requests
        • Installation - VMs or CI run
      • Cover Pipeline for GitLab
        • Introduction
        • Installation and initial setup
        • GitLab workflow
        • Configuration
        • Troubleshooting
        • Related topics
      • Cover Pipeline for GitHub
        • Introduction
        • Installation and initial setup
        • GitHub workflow
        • Configuration
        • Troubleshooting
        • Related topics
    • Cover Reports
      • Cover Reports Contributor
        • Java project config (JaCoCo)
        • Generate and upload reports bundles
        • Authenticated uploads
      • Cover Reports User
        • Navigation
        • Dashboards
        • Telemetry data
        • Export API
        • Considerations
      • Cover Reports Administrator
        • Install and update Cover Reports
        • Configuration options
        • Database backup
        • SSO with Cover Reports
        • Uninstall Cover Reports
    • Cover Optimize
      • Get started - Cover Optimize
      • Cover Optimize & Gradle
      • Cover Optimize & Maven
      • Patch files
    • Cover Refactor
      • Get started - Cover Refactor
    • Cover Annotations
      • Mocking Annotations
      • Custom Input Annotations
      • Interesting Value Annotations
    • Output Codes
      • E - Environment Codes
      • L - License Codes
      • R - Reason Codes
      • T - Testability Codes
      • V - Validation Codes
      • Working with output codes
        • Working with code E020
        • Working with codes E057 to E065
        • Working with code E085
        • Working with code R005
        • Working with code R006
        • Working with code R008
        • Working with code R011
        • Working with code R012
        • Working with code R013
        • Working with code R026
        • Working with code R031
        • Working with code V003
    • Tutorials
      • How to measure test quality
      • How to improve code coverage
      • How to test a new feature
      • How to find regressions
      • How to use Diffblue Cover in test driven development (TDD)
      • How to write tests for Kotlin projects
      • Examples of tests created by Diffblue Cover
      • Best practices for testing private methods
  • Updates & Upgrades
    • Update Cover
    • Cover Editions
    • What's new
    • Release archive
      • 2025-05-01
      • 2025-04-02
      • 2025-04-01
      • 2025-03-02
      • 2025-03-01
      • 2025-02-02
      • 2025-02-01
      • 2025-01-02
      • 2025-01-01
      • 2024-12-02
      • 2024-12-01
      • 2024-11-02
      • 2024-11-01
      • 2024-10-02
      • 2024-10-01
      • 2024-09-02
      • 2024-09-01
      • 2024-08-02
      • 2024-08-01
      • 2024-07-04
      • 2024-07-03
      • 2024-07-01
      • 2024-06-02
      • 2024-06-01
      • 2024-05-02
      • 2024-05-01
      • 2024-04-02
      • 2024-04-01
      • 2024-03-02
      • 2024-03-01
      • 2024-02-02
      • 2024-02-01
      • 2024-01-02
      • 2024-01-01
      • 2023-12-02
      • 2023-12-01
      • 2023-11-03
      • 2023-11-02
      • 2023-11-01
      • 2023-10-02
      • 2023-10-01
      • 2023-09-02
      • 2023-09-01
      • 2023-08-02
      • 2023-08-01
      • 2023-07-03
      • 2023-07-02
      • 2023-07-01
      • 2023-06-02
      • 2023-06-01
      • 2023-05-02
      • 2023-05-01
      • 2023-04-02
      • 2023-04-01
      • 2023-03-02
      • 2023-03-01
      • 2023-02-02
      • 2023-02-01
      • 2023-01-02
      • 2023-01-01
      • 2022-12-02
      • 2022-12-01
      • 2022-11-02
      • 2022-11-01
      • 2022-10-03
      • 2022-10-02
      • 2022-10-01
      • 2022-09-02
      • 2022-09-01
      • 2022-08-05
      • 2022-08-03
      • 2022-08-02
      • 2022-08-01
      • 2022-07-02
      • 2022-07-01
      • 2022-06-02
      • 2022-06-01
      • 2022-05-02
      • 2022-05-01
      • 2022-04-02
      • 2022-04-01
      • 2022-03-02
      • 2022-03-01
      • 2022-02-02
      • 2022-02-01
      • 2022-01-02
      • 2022-01-01
      • 2021-06-02
      • 2021-02-01
  • Legal
    • Diffblue Legal
      • Diffblue End User License Agreement (EULA)
      • Cover Third Party Notices and/or Licenses
      • Privacy Notice
Powered by GitBook
On this page

Was this helpful?

Export as PDF
  1. Features
  2. Tutorials

Best practices for testing private methods

It is good practice to break down the logic of complex public methods into private methods. For instance:

public class Palindrome {
  private final Path inputFile;

  public Palindrome(Path inputFile) {
    this.inputFile = inputFile;
  }
  
  public boolean check() {
    return Files.lines(inputFile)
      .stream()
      .allMatch(s -> new StringBuilder(s).reverse().toString().equals(s));
  }
}

After splitting out the palindrome check for a single line, we have:

public class Palindrome {
  private final Path inputFile;

  public Palindrome(Path inputFile) {
    this.inputFile = inputFile;
  }
  
  public boolean check() {
    return Files.lines(inputFile).stream().allMatch(this::isPalindrome);
  }
  
  private boolean isPalindrome(String s) {
    return new StringBuilder(s).reverse().toString().equals(s);
  }
}

This looks much more approachable now. The private method could even be made static in this case. However, for testing the logic in this private method we have introduced another obstacle because they cannot be directly called from test cases anymore. Using reflection to call private methods would result in brittle test code that is hard to automatically refactor and is thus not recommended.

The recommended approach is to

  • make the methods package-private and

  • annotate them with @VisibleForTesting .

This annotation is available from several libraries such as Guava, Jetbrains Annotations and Assert4J.

It doesn't matter which of these libraries we choose; so, let's add the following to our build configuration, for instance:

      <dependency>
        <groupId>com.google.guava</groupId>
        <artifactId>guava</artifactId>
        <version>33.4.8-jre</version>
      </dependency>

And then apply our recommendation:

public class Palindrome {
  private final Path inputFile;

  public Palindrome(Path inputFile) {
    this.inputFile = inputFile;
  }
  
  public boolean check() {
    return Files.lines(inputFile).stream().allMatch(this::isPalindrome);
  }
  
  @VisibleForTesting
  boolean isPalindrome(String s) {
    return new StringBuilder(s).reverse().toString().equals(s);
  }
}

Now we can easily test the single-line palindrome check without requiring reflection or setting up a test scenario with actual input files.

If you are worried about having loosened encapsulation, note that, additionally, an arch-unit test could be configured to ensure that these now package-private methods are only called from the scope of the class or the tests, but this is out of scope of this tutorial.

PreviousExamples of tests created by Diffblue CoverNextUpdate Cover

Last updated 1 day ago

Was this helpful?